In November 1959, Raymond Poole, a 33-year-old college graduate, went to the Ballroom Dance Studio to redeem a certificate entitling him to three free dance lessons. At that time, he lived alone in a one-room attic apartment. During the free lessons, the instructor told Poole that he had “the potential to be a fine, accomplished dancer.” Poole then signed up for more lessons. He attended lessons regularly and was praised and encouraged by the instructors despite his lack of progress. Contract extensions and new contracts for additional instructional hours were executed, which Poole prepaid. Each written contract contained the bold-type words, “Noncancellable contract.”
On September 24, 1961, Poole was severely injured in an automobile accident. At that time he had contracted for a total of 2,734 hours of dance lessons, for which he had prepaid $24,812. When the Ballroom Dance Studio refused to refund any of his money, Poole sued to end the outstanding contracts and recover the money for his prepaid lessons. What argument(s) can Poole use to end the contracts? What argument(s) will the Ballroom Dance Studio make? Decide who will succeed.
No comments:
Post a Comment